James is experienced in both wet and dry shipping. James’ dry shipping practice consists mainly of complicated charterparty, bill of lading and shipbuilding/sale and purchase disputes raising novel issues but James also deals on a regular basis with more run-of-the-mill disputes concerning off-hire, hold-cleaning, oil major approvals, responsibility for taxes, unsafe port claims, laytime and demurrage, speed and performance, the Inter-Club Agreement and formation/termination.
James has had an article about The Astra published in the Law Quarterly Review: On the Classification of Amphibious Avians (and Contractual Terms): The Astra, LQR 2014, 185 (Apr).
James is a Supporting Member of the LMAA.
Examples of work include:
Charterparties, Bills of Lading, etc
- MUR Shipping BV v RTI Ltd [2022] EWCA Civ 1406; [2022] EWHC 467 (Comm) - James successfully represented the appellant COA charterers in this appeal concerning the construction of a force majeure clause and its application to sanctions that hindered payments of freight in US dollars.
- Ocean Prefect [2020] EWHC 3368 (Comm). Commercial Court. Use of MAIB reports in maritime arbitration.
- Commercial Court, LMAA Arbitration: 2-day trial before LMAA arbitrators involving cross-examination of expert witness, followed by appeal under ss. 68 and 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996. Demurrage claim under voyage charter arising out of delay to vessel at Kandla following arrival of damaged cargo of phenol. Related proceedings due for trial in 2020.
- Arbitration: multi-million dollar damages claims under long-term contract concerning the supply of transport for bauxite raising US sanctions and frustration issues.
- Advisory: advising time charterers on their rights during the blockade of Qatar.
- LMAA Arbitration: four-day trial of disputes arising in chain of Synacomex charterparties involving issues as to the identity of the parties, allegations of email fabrication requiring forensic evidence, and restitution.
- LMAA Arbitration: claim arising out of termination of luxury yacht charter.
- LMAA Arbitration: US$100M time charter arbitration arising out of the detention of a vessel at a South American port involving unsafe port issues and issues in relation to steps taken in order to release the vessel from detention and settle claims against the vessel. Led by Elizabeth Blackburn QC.
- LMAA Arbitration: time charter cancellation/repudiation/hold-cleaning dispute leading to a 4-day liability and quantum trial in Singapore. James appeared as sole counsel for the shipowners, cross-examining 4 witnesses, including 2 expert witnesses. Tribunal’s award gave James’s clients a comprehensive victory.
- London Arbitration 2/16 (LMLN 5 February 2016): multi-million dollar arbitration arising out of various agreements in relation to the use of a vessel in the offshore oil industry involving serious allegations of fraud. 5-day trial including cross-examination.
- Isabella Shipowner SA v. Shagang Shipping Co Ltd, “AQUAFAITH” [2012] EWHC 1077 (Comm), led by Tim Hill QC, acting for the successful owners in appeal from arbitrator under s. 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996 regarding decision on the width of a shipowner’s right to refuse early redelivery under a period time charter.
- Several post-Aquafaith time charter redelivery disputes concerning the effect of that decision and raising issues of mitigation, quantum and penalty clauses.
- Commercial Court: proceedings ancillary to the proceedings in Eurobank Ergasias SA v. Kalliroi Navigation [2015] EWHC 2377 (Comm); advising on urgent interpleader proceedings arising out of a shipowner’s alleged assignment of freight to a mortgagee, including issues relating to service out and underlying GAFTA soybean meal sale contract.
- LMAA Arbitration: ad hoc arbitration arising out of a voyage charter for an oil cargo. Demurrage dispute raising a question about the Master’s duty to sign bills of lading, complicated issues as to the correct parties to the charter, and detailed expert evidence on the measurement of oil cargoes.
- LMAA Arbitration: time charter arbitration arising out of call at Yemen in 2015 involving a variety of war risks issues, Conwartime 2004 and the BIMCO Piracy Clause.
- LMAA Arbitration: charterparty chain arbitration involving issues of hull damage and stevedore negligence exclusions.
- LMAA Arbitration: acting as sole counsel for successful owners in multi-million dollar Supplytime dispute arising out of multiple contracts for the hire of vessels in the Arabian Gulf. Wide-ranging dispute involving novel construction issues arising out of bespoke ‘punchlist’ provisions. Matter went to a five-day trial in October 2014. Following an award upholding James’s clients’ claims in all respects, James dealt with further costs and enforcement issues.
- LMAA Arbitration: voyage charter arbitration arising out of a charter on the Australian Wheat Form and giving rise to an issue as to the recoverability by charterers from owners of a ‘fine’ levied at the loading port in Australia.
- Advisory: off hire and termination dispute arising out of a time charter on the ShellLNGTime form and involving questions of whether the vessel had failed an inspection and the prevention of normal commercial operations.
- Advisory: repudiation dispute arising out of a charter on the Shelltime 4 form and involving a refusal to follow orders to load ship-to-ship, war risks issues and the impact of hedging on quantum.
- LMAA Arbitration: detention dispute arising out of bespoke booking note and giving rise to complicated issues of construction.
- LMAA Arbitration related to Seawolf Tankers Inc, Heidmar Inc v. Pan Ocean Co. Limited [2015] EWHC 1500 (Ch) and giving rise to issues as to the effect on a pool agreement of insolvency proceedings.
- LMAA Arbitrations arising out of bill of lading for carriage of cargo to Jordan involving issues of causation arising out of the authorities’ response to wet damage and of jurisdiction in circumstances where the bill provided for English arbitration but proceedings had been started in Jordan in accordance with the Hamburg Rules.
- LMAA Arbitration: acting for charterers of self-propelled barges for use in an offshore construction project in an arbitration raising delay, termination, repudiation and misrepresentation issues.
- LMAA Arbitration arising out of charter on the Asbatankvoy form and giving rise to issues of detention/demurrage and damage to a phenol cargo.
- LMAA Arbitration arising out of charter on the Shelltime 4 form and giving rise to issues as to the vessel’s SIRE status and fitness to obtain business from oil majors and other similar entities.
- LMAA Arbitration arising out of NYPE time charter and involving an owner’s protracted refusal to follow orders, giving rise to issues as to the effect of a failure to comply with insurance obligations, duress, off-hire, and the English court’s jurisdiction to permit service out.
- LMAA Arbitration: five-day arbitration in Hong Kong arising out of multiple COAs. US$50M dispute relating to shipments of iron ore. Dispute involved the construction of various bespoke washout agreements, as well as issues of rectification and illegality.
- LMAA arbitrations: multi-million dollar time and voyage charter arbitrations arising out of disputes as to responsibility for Chinese taxes and involving construction, restitution and illegality issues.
- LMAA arbitration: successful award on preliminary demurrage time bar issue after two-day hearing as sole counsel and subsequently obtained a further award requiring the costs of the preliminary issue to be paid forthwith.
- LMAA arbitration: recently attended as sole counsel for the mediation of a cranes and underperformance dispute.
- LMAA arbitration: voyage charter reference involving issues as to the identity of the parties to the fixture, agency, undisclosed principals and frustration.
- LMAA arbitration: COA reference arising out of dispute over operation of VoyWar 2004 in the context of piracy, involving issues of duress, mistake, restitution and liens.
- Commercial Court: acted for shipowner in claim arising out of complex compromise of forward freight contracts involving fraud, conspiracy, knowing receipt, dishonest assistance and challenging a fraudulent transaction under s. 423 Insolvency Act 1986.
- Hong Kong arbitration: off-hire dispute in a chain of time and trip charters raising issue as to whether and to what extent the charters have the same meaning and effect, as well as issues relating to low-sulphur fuel requirements and fraudulent bills of lading.
- Perseveranza SpA v. Western Bulk Carriers, the “NEWLEAD MARKELA”, Claim No. 2010 Folio 1172: dispute arising out of the settlement of certain time charter claims and raising issues of construction and rectification.
- LMAA arbitration: hull-fouling dispute raising issue as to a shipowner’s right to recover hire credits allowed to his next charterer in respect of speed and performance claims.
- Commercial Court: obtaining urgent ship inspection/disclosure (‘Vasso’) order on behalf of cargo interests.
Ship Sale and Purchase
- Advisory: advising buyers on termination/cancellation rights and strategy in dispute arising out of MOA on SALEFORM 1993 form in circumstances where market values had fallen sharply since MOA was made, and in which the MOA had adopted elements of an underlying shipbuilding contract.
- ICDR Arbitration: reference arising out of abortive sale by James’s clients of a semi-submersible drilling rig involving issues of construction, termination, repudiation and damages.
- LMAA arbitration: $50M ship sale dispute concerning issues of NOR validity and effect.
- LMAA arbitration: acted as sole counsel in arbitration relating to damage caused by premature service of NOR.
- Admiralty Court: acting for and advising good faith purchaser of an unregistered ship alleged to be subject to a ship mortgage.
Wet shipping/Admiralty Court
- Nautical Challenge v. Evergreen Marine; first collision appeal on liability to reach Court of Appeal since 2004 (appeal concerned interaction of crossing rules and narrow channel rule), large claim arising out of 2015 Jebel Ali collision between oil tanker and container ship; first instance at [2022] EWHC 830 (Admlty) (consequentials) [2022] EWHC 206 (Admlty) (re-apportionment) [2021] UKSC 6 (liability appeal)
[2018] EWCA Civ 2173 (liability appeal) [2017] EWHC 453 (Admlty) (liability trial); led by Vasanti Selvaratnam QC.
- MSC Madrid/Primula Seaways, acted for MSC Madrid in collision action between two ships off Flushing.
- Voge Emma/Nordic Riga, acted for Voge Emma in collision action between two ships who were at anchor.
- Advisory: advising on quantum in relation to collision between vessels following earlier collision involving one of the vessels and associated detention/causation issues.
- Bolero Trading v. Mersey Docks, the “ANTONIS”, Claim No. 2012 Folio 746: acted for port defending allision claim; involved risk assessment issues.
- SUNFLOWER E”, Claim No. 2105 Folio 729: crew wages claim following arrest of vessel at Newport in 2015 and involving issues of foreign law and insolvency.
- Leeming v. Leeming, the “FAT SWAN”, Claim No. 2015 Folio 108: dispute over ownership of a vessel involving resulting and constructive trusts issues and allegations of fraud.
- Advisory: advising owner of a vessel involved in a collision in a Traffic Separation Scheme on the proper construction of the COLREGS.
- “Dona Liberta”, Claim No. 2011 Folio 928: advising shipowners with vessel under arrest in the UK on security and strategy.